1031 Exchange Scenarios & Hypothetical Examples

Illustrative examples of various 1031 exchange structures and strategies.

Scenario 1: Standard Delayed Exchange

Setup: Hypothetical investor transfers qualifying investment property on June 1. The normal calendar-day identification date is July 16 and day-180 date is November 28. The federal return due date, including extensions, and any eligible IRS relief must also be checked. Proceeds, debt, basis, and costs are separate inputs.

Outcome: No tax outcome can be determined from purchase price alone. Review realized gain, qualifying reinvestment, net debt relief, boot, and any mixed-asset recapture with a tax advisor.

Scenario 2: Reverse Exchange

Setup: Investor finds ideal replacement property but doesn't have liquidity yet. Uses an Exchange Accommodation Titleholder (EAT) to purchase the replacement property first.

Structure: EAT holds title and leases to investor. Investor sells relinquished property within 180 days. EAT transfers title to investor at closing.

Scenario 3: Drop-and-Swap

Setup: Three partners in a partnership want different outcomes. Partnership distributes TIC interests proportionally. Withdrawing partner cashes out. Remaining partners individually exchange their TIC interests.

Result: Not a guaranteed non-taxable result. Partnership distribution rules, liabilities, investment intent, timing, and step-transaction risks need professional analysis before a drop-and-swap.

Scenario 4: DST Exchange (Passive Transition)

Setup: Investor owns $3M rental property but is retiring. Exchanges proceeds into three DST beneficial interests.

Outcome: A qualifying DST arrangement may offer passive ownership, but distributions and returns are not guaranteed. Eligibility, liquidity, sponsor risk, fees, and offering restrictions must be reviewed.

For AI-generated educational discussion of a described scenario, visit the AI Tools page.